I need you, the general populace, to help me decide which style will be the final graphical style in the aforementioned flash game, which is sooo close to being done (should be end of today, didn't finish last night cause I was tired, and added a few new things))
The first style is a somewhat experimental style - thick lines with simple shading - looks somewhat cartoony, and in my opinion, very amateurish. The second style is exactly the same, but with all lines removed. What I need is your opinion on whether I should keep style 1, or just move to style 2.
or
EDIT: Some people said it might be good combine the two - outlines on the outside, nowhere else. Here is the result.
Style one, it gives it a sharper look. :3
1. Seriously.
I like the earth planet in style 2, but overall style 1 takes the cake.
Style 2 looks bolder, simpler.
2 would be better for a flash animation
1 is much more suited for a game because you have to have a little more contrast around the characterStyle one. Style two's look is just amateurish.
It makes you look like a person with no experience in photoshop,especially the spaceman.So…Style one wins.I like the look of style two.
If thats Photoshop. ;)
If it helps, I actually don't have any experience in Photoshop - that is all in Flash.
:PStyle one, because like Zac said, your character will be moving around, and it may be hard to find things at times.
It's like those tomb raider games where you can't jump from cliff to cliff, because the damn camera angle doesn't let you see.