Killing Insects, Vegetarianism etc.

Posted by RabbidMickeyMouse on Aug. 26, 2007, 7:50 p.m.

I remember as a child my older brother Jeremiah sweeping downstairs, and saw a large ant on the floor, crawling along unassumingly. He had already grown tired of sweeping, and upon seeing the ant, rather than simply sweep it away, he raised the broom and jabbed the broom towards the ground until he was sure it was dead. I felt sorry for the ant, as I always seem to do for insects and small animals when killed by humans.

I've seen children (and teenagers alike) find a colony of ants crawling and dissecting food that had fallen onto the sidewalk and forgotten about, raise their feet, stomp, and wipe the entrails of thousands of ants across the immediate area. Most in my position would argue the hypothetical, "What if a huge foot came across our own town and did what you’re doing?". I however never took up that position much as most had heard it all before, and the thought never provoked much fear in others, only more imaginative scenarios.

Its not that I'm needlessly sensitive about the welfare of these creatures, its simply I'd rather not kill them myself without an intelligent reason. Its not hard to believe this may connected to my fear of death, whereas the deaths of those insects and animals has me doubt any purposeful meaning behind life, especially intelligent life in the case of humans when we're easily led away from reason.

I'm not a vegetarian, nor do I plan on becoming one, and although I detest the unnecessary killing of insects, animals, and plants, I recognize that as a species designed to eat meat (and in possession of an enlarged brain thanks to eating meat), our domestication of cattle, chicken and so on is primarily a matter of our own survival, if not at least our health.

I haven't personally discussed vegetarianism with very many, so I shouldn't argue against their beliefs. I will however continue to ponder the irony of seeing nothing wrong with wild animals, whose bodies are designed to consume meat, hunt and kill prey for their flesh. Does our increased intelligence somehow play a factor? I understand that as intelligent as humans have become in changing their environment, that overkill is an issue, but that aside of course, is it believed that the more intelligent we become, the less likely we are (or should be) to kill for the sake of eating? I don’t know as I should point out again.

On one hand, I find it disheartening about our collective intellectual worth as a species if many of us as children and presently find entertainment, or indifference to the unprovoked or unnecessary killing of other living things, which keeps me believing there's a purpose to how I feel about these things, that others agree, and that it serves a purpose to keeping people mindful about this issue. On the other hand, removing my sense of superiority over insects and animals, as defensive as I am for the own welfare, I begin to think that my own existence is as meaningless as there's if it can be ended as easily as theirs was.

There are those who argue that as intelligent, creative minds, our existence is not meaningless as long as we're motivated to create, adapt and carry on our own ideas. I have my doubts as usual. There’s too much to consider before I begin to believe that there’s a purpose to life, the universe and everything if it was all created without reason and will very well end without reason.

Yet another vague blog entry. Hope you enjoyed!

Comments

JID 17 years, 2 months ago

@ Firefly I love killing defenseless insects :)

DIE DIE DIE DIE DIE!!!!

Oh, and btw..

All Your Base ARE BELONG TO US!

Tasm 17 years, 2 months ago

REZ, you don't watch MythBusters much, do you?

F1ak3r 17 years, 2 months ago

My opinion: We have souls. They don't. Our lives have meaning. Theirs don't.

Grand-High Gamer 17 years, 2 months ago

My opinion: Shut the fuck up, bitch.

What threat is there in ants and other defenseless animals. It's not like they're gonna gang up on you.

E-Magination 17 years, 2 months ago

Their lives have more meaning than ours. They don't have useless wastes of intelligence like archeology or wastes of money like space travel.

Cesque 17 years, 2 months ago

Quote:
Wow, my view is the complete opposite. I see it this way: Would humans even exist right now, and be on the top of the food chain if we didn't practice the killing of innocent animals? Certainly not. Kill or be killed. That's nature.

Nature's cruel designs should not to be taken for granted. I am one of the people who believe that one of the major factors shaping intelligence is predation. But I can't see how eating meat nowadays, which has absolutely nothing to do with predation, can be justified by your sort of logic.

Quote:
You don't need that. The purpose of life is to reproduce mindlessly and cause mankind's own destruction, since you really can't do much else. So enjoy it while you can.

That's the purpose of life only if accept nothing else. And I wouldn't call it "purpose", really, it's more of a natural mechanic.

Great entry there, RMM. I have to say that I hate senseless killing of any organism. If you have to clean a house and sweep away the spider, or if you accidentally bring about the demise of some creature, it happens - but why kill something for no reason other than to kill it? It's plain senseless. I don't believe it's catastrophic, or terrible, or that the insects feel suffering or anything of this sort - but it still just doesn't make any goddamn sense.

And I am not a vegetarian or fanatical about it, either - though I usually don't eat red (mammal) meat for reasons other than moral, but I'm still a person of great empathy. Not really towards insects. But when I hear of a person drowning a dog in a bucket or abandoning a puppy in a forest, I tend to get pissed.